Miscommunication Research Project
Initial Research & Summary: 2018 VA Medical Center Service Animal Crisis
What Happened?
​
In 2018, multiple reports surfaced involving veterans being denied entry or services at various Veterans Affairs (VA) Medical Centers due to disputes over service animals. The most notable incidents included veterans being asked to leave or denied care unless they could prove their dogs were certified service animals, despite the ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) not requiring certification for public access. One highly publicized case involved a veteran with PTSD being escorted out of a VA hospital in North Carolina after refusing to produce documentation for his dog.
​
These incidents drew criticism for violating federal disability rights, and they highlighted internal confusion within VA systems about ADA guidelines. The public backlash intensified when video clips were shared online, showing security or staff dismissing or mishandling veterans who depended on service animals for support.
Timeline :
Pre-2018: Foundation of VA Service Animal Policies​​
Early 2018
Complaints rise about inconsistent service animal policies across VA centers.
-
January–February 2018: Veterans report inconsistent enforcement of service animal policies across various VA Medical Centers. Some veterans with legitimate service dogs face access denials or are asked for documentation not required under ADA guidelines.
-
March 2018: A notable incident occurs at a VA facility in North Carolina, where a veteran with a PTSD service dog is denied entry due to lack of certification papers. The incident gains media attention, highlighting the confusion and inconsistent application of service animal policies within VA facilities.
MID 2018
Public outrage grows; ADA and veterans' advocacy groups respond.
The Department of Veterans Affairs issues updated guidance to clarify service animal policy, emphasizing ADA compliance.
-
May 2018: In response to mounting concerns, the VA reaffirms its commitment to ADA-aligned policies, emphasizing that staff may only ask two specific questions to determine if a dog is a service animal:
-
Is the dog a service animal required because of a disability?
-
What work or task has the dog been trained to perform?
Staff are reminded not to request documentation or ask the dog to demonstrate tasks .
-
-
June 2018: The VA issues updated guidance to all facilities, reinforcing the definitions and access rights of service animals. The guidance specifies that only dogs trained to perform tasks for individuals with disabilities are recognized as service animals, excluding emotional support animals from this classification
LATE 2018
Ongoing media scrutiny and advocacy pressure lead to internal reviews and calls for staff retraining.
​
-
July–August 2018: VA facilities begin staff training sessions to ensure consistent understanding and application of service animal policies. Facility directors are tasked with appointing staff members responsible for overseeing compliance with these policies.
-
September 2018: The VA emphasizes the importance of accommodating veterans with service animals while maintaining safety and infection control standards. Policies are adjusted to allow service animals in most areas, with exceptions for specific zones like operating rooms .
